Pricing is one of the most crucial decisions you’ll make as an agency owner. Yet, many people approach it the wrong way—they look around at what their competitors are charging and base their prices on that. While it might seem logical, this approach can actually hurt your profitability and limit your growth. Instead, the right way to price your services is to look inward at your own costs, value, and market position.
Here’s a proven strategy to set prices that maximize your profit, strengthen your competitive edge, and help you grow a sustainable agency.
Why Copying Competitors’ Prices Doesn’t Work
Too often, agency owners want to know what everyone else is charging as a guide to their own pricing. But this method is deeply flawed. Just because a competitor is charging a certain rate doesn’t mean it’s right for you. Your cost structure, target market, and value proposition are unique to your agency, so your pricing should be too.
Here’s a better approach: Focus on your own numbers. If you can be more profitable at a lower price than your competitors, you’ll have the flexibility to undercut them, provided you still deliver excellent results. Conversely, if your agency is producing stellar outcomes that no one else can match, you might be able to command much higher prices. The key is to make pricing decisions that align with your unique value and business goals, not with what others are doing.
The 3.5x Rule: A Reliable Pricing Foundation
To ensure you’re pricing for profit, you need a solid baseline for your services. A good starting point is to set your price at at least 3.5 times your cost of production. This means that if it costs you $1,000 to complete a project, you should aim to charge a minimum of $3,500.
Why 3.5x? Here’s the breakdown:
- Cover Direct Costs: First, your price needs to cover all the direct expenses associated with delivering your service, such as labor, materials, and any third-party costs.
- Account for Overheads: Your agency has operating expenses, from office space and software subscriptions to marketing and team salaries. Pricing at 3.5x allows you to factor these in without cutting into your profit.
- Ensure Profitability: By marking up your services by at least 3.5x, you’re building a margin that supports sustainable profitability. This buffer helps absorb any unexpected expenses and keeps your agency financially healthy.
Setting prices at 3.5x is a foundational strategy, but remember, this is just a starting point. If your agency is producing above-market results, you may be able to charge even more. On the other hand, if you can achieve this margin with a lower price while maintaining quality, you may choose to do so strategically. The bottom line is to have a price that both covers costs and aligns with the level of value you bring.
High or Low: Why the Middle Ground Is Risky
When it comes to pricing, many agency owners feel pressure to price in the middle of the market, thinking it’s a safe spot. However, the middle ground can be the most dangerous place to be. Why? Because when the market tightens, mid-range agencies are often the first to get squeezed—by both high-end and low-end competitors.
If you’re on the higher end of the pricing spectrum, you attract clients who value premium service and are willing to pay for it. These clients are less likely to jump ship over a few dollars and often appreciate the quality you provide. To justify these higher prices, focus on delivering exceptional results and a great client experience.
On the flip side, if you’re the cheapest in the market but still profitable, you have the advantage of accessibility, appealing to budget-conscious clients who are looking for results without a high price tag. If you can consistently provide quality work at a lower cost, you’ll have a competitive edge over agencies that can’t match your efficiency.
The key takeaway? Avoid the temptation to blend in with middle-of-the-road pricing. Either position yourself as the best (and most expensive) or the most accessible (and best value). Trying to please everyone with moderate pricing can lead to squeezed margins and a weaker position in the market.
Pricing with Facts, Not Feelings
Pricing decisions should always be made based on facts, not feelings. As the agency owner, you have to remove any emotional attachment from the process and make decisions like a true CEO. Evaluate your costs, assess the market demand, and understand the value you deliver. By making data-driven pricing decisions, you can set rates that support your growth and protect your profit margins.
Track your costs closely and review them regularly. As your agency grows, your costs will likely increase, so be ready to adjust your prices accordingly. For example, if you add new services or expand your team, your costs will rise, and you’ll need to factor that into your pricing to ensure you remain profitable.
Final Thoughts
Setting the right price for your services isn’t about what others are charging; it’s about knowing your costs, value, and business goals. By following the 3.5x rule, choosing a strong market position, and making pricing decisions based on facts, you’ll create a pricing strategy that supports long-term success.
Don’t miss out on more insights like these at the upcoming Agency Freedom Live event. Join us to dive deeper into strategies for building a profitable, scalable agency.